When comparing entry-level riding lawn mowers, two models stand out for their affordability, simplicity, and solid reputations—Craftsman T110 vs John Deere S100. Both of these machines are built with the typical homeowner in mind, targeting lawns under two acres while delivering dependable mowing performance at a budget-friendly price.
However, the differences in engine quality, transmission type, cutting deck design, and overall usability can significantly impact the long-term value each model provides. In this in-depth comparison of the Craftsman T110 vs John Deere S100, we break down all the key categories to help homeowners select the most reliable and comfortable ride-on mower for their property.
Contents
Differences Craftsman T110 vs John Deere S100
Engine Power and Performance
Both the Craftsman T110 and the John Deere S100 come equipped with a single-cylinder Briggs & Stratton 17.5 HP engine with a 500cc displacement. This configuration is standard for entry-level riding mowers and delivers enough power to handle lawns between 0.5 and 1.5 acres efficiently. It runs cleanly and provides consistent mowing strength for general grass cutting, especially on flat terrain.
While the engines are nearly identical on paper, John Deere fine-tunes its engine calibration, optimizing fuel consumption and throttle response to match the S100’s hydrostatic drivetrain. This integration provides slightly better power-to-control synchronization, especially when changing speeds frequently in complex yard layouts.
Winner: John Deere S100
Although both engines are identical in output, better drivetrain integration gives the S100 a slight edge in responsiveness and efficiency during variable mowing conditions.
Transmission System Comparison
The Craftsman T110 utilizes a 7-speed manual transmission, operated via a lever on the fender. While durable and simple to repair, this system requires users to manually shift gears and stop the mower during transitions. This can be cumbersome when mowing around obstacles, inclines, or varying terrain.
The John Deere S100 features a hydrostatic transmission controlled by a foot pedal, offering seamless forward and reverse transitions. This setup allows users to control speed intuitively with their feet while keeping their hands on the wheel, significantly improving mowing fluidity and user comfort.
Winner: John Deere S100
The hydrostatic foot-pedal transmission delivers smoother acceleration and more precise speed control, especially for beginners or users working in complex lawn layouts.
Cutting Deck and Mowing Performance
Both the T110 and S100 come with a 42-inch stamped steel deck, ideal for covering medium-sized properties quickly while remaining narrow enough for gates and tight turns. Constructed from 13-gauge steel, these decks offer decent durability for routine use on relatively flat terrain.
The Craftsman T110 provides a cutting height range from 1.25 inches to 3.75 inches, while the S100 extends the range slightly from 1 inch to 4 inches. This added range gives the S100 greater flexibility for mowing in different seasons, especially when handling tall spring growth or drought-stressed summer turf.
Winner: John Deere S100
With wider cutting height adjustability and more mowing precision, the S100 provides better lawn customization across different grass types and weather conditions.
Fuel Capacity and Runtime Efficiency
Fuel capacity directly affects how long a rider can mow without refueling. The Craftsman T110 has a 1.3-gallon fuel tank, suitable for lawns under an acre but limiting for longer sessions or properties with hills and obstacles.
The John Deere S100 boasts a 2.4-gallon fuel tank, nearly doubling the runtime. This is especially beneficial for owners of 1.5-acre properties or those who mow less frequently and prefer longer sessions without interruption.
Winner: John Deere S100
The larger tank provides better runtime efficiency, reducing fuel stops and increasing productivity on larger lawns.
Comfort and Ergonomic Design
The Craftsman T110 includes a mid-back seat with basic padding and no lumbar support. While fine for shorter use, it lacks long-term comfort and may cause fatigue during extended mowing.
The S100 improves on this with a high-back seat featuring built-in lumbar support, plus easier-to-reach controls, a more ergonomic steering wheel, and vibration-dampening foot rests. It also includes standard LED headlights, allowing use during early mornings or late evenings.
Winner: John Deere S100
With better seat support, improved ergonomics, and added visibility features, the S100 is significantly more comfortable and functional for prolonged mowing.
Handling and Maneuverability
Both mowers offer an 18-inch turning radius, which is standard for entry-level models. This is adequate for general lawn mowing but may require multiple-point turns in tight corners or when maneuvering around landscaping.
However, the hydrostatic control system on the S100 allows for smoother directional changes and better precision in navigating tight spots, while the manual gear-based system on the T110 demands more stop-start action and planning.
Winner: John Deere S100
Thanks to foot-pedal control and smoother transitions, the S100 provides easier navigation, especially in complex mowing paths.
Build Quality and Long-Term Durability
The Craftsman T110 offers solid build quality for its price, with a steel hood and reinforced deck mounts. However, its frame construction is lighter and less refined than the S100, and the mower lacks many of the anti-corrosion coatings or weather-resistant finishes found on higher-tier models.
The John Deere S100, built at the company’s Greenville, Tennessee plant, features a robotically welded steel frame with E-coat corrosion protection, offering better longevity in harsh conditions. The overall component fit and finish are tighter, and the machine feels more solid during operation.
Winner: John Deere S100
The heavier-duty construction, coating protection, and tighter tolerances ensure the S100 offers greater structural integrity and a longer lifespan.
Features and Customization
The Craftsman T110 includes only the basics—no headlights, no cruise control, and no mulching kit unless purchased separately. It’s designed as a simple mower without extra comforts.
The John Deere S100 includes headlights, a deck wash port, and compatibility with a wider range of attachments such as baggers, snow blades, and dump carts. Mulching capability can be added with an optional kit, and the mower’s intuitive dashboard makes accessory installation more user-friendly.
Winner: John Deere S100
With more built-in features and better accessory support, the S100 is clearly the more versatile and upgrade-ready platform.
Quick Rundown Of Craftsman T110
Quick Rundown Of John Deere S100
Conclusion
Choose the Craftsman T110 if you’re looking for a budget-friendly riding mower for a smaller, flat yard and prefer a manual, no-frills machine that gets the job done. It’s ideal for first-time buyers with a compact garage and minimal feature requirements.
Choose the John Deere S100 if you value user comfort, smoother performance, and long-term reliability. Its hydrostatic drive, larger tank, and stronger build make it ideal for homeowners who want better control and enhanced comfort while mowing larger or more varied properties.
Overall Winner: John Deere S100
With superior transmission, comfort, fuel capacity, and structural design, the S100 clearly stands above the T110 in almost every important category. It’s the smarter long-term investment for homeowners seeking a durable and user-friendly lawn tractor.